Arc magmatic evolution and the construction of continental crust at the Central American Volcanic Arc system

Scott A. Whattam, Robert J. Stern

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

7 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Whether or not magmatic arcs evolve compositionally with time and the processes responsible remain controversial. Resolution of this question requires the reconstruction of arc geochemical evolution at the level of a discrete arc system. Here, we address this problem using the well-studied Central American Volcanic Arc System (CAVAS) as an example. Geochemical and isotopic data were compiled for 1031 samples of lavas and intrusive rocks from the ~1100 km-long segment of oceanic CAVAS (Panama, Costa Rica, Nicaragua) built on thickened oceanic crust over its 75 million year lifespan. We used available age constraints to subdivide this data set into six magmatic phases: 75-39 Ma (Phase I or PI); 35-16 Ma (PII); 16-6 Ma (PIII); 6-3 Ma (PIV); 5.9-0.01 Ma (PVa arc alkaline and PVb adakitic); and 2.6-0 Ma (PVI, Quaternary to modern magmatism, predominantly 蠐 1 Ma). To correct for magmatic fractionation, selected major and trace element abundances were linearly regressed to 55 wt.% SiO2. The most striking observation is the overall evolution of the CAVAS to more incompatible element enriched and ultimately continental-like compositions with time, although magmatic evolution took on a more regional character in the youngest rocks, with magmatic rocks of Nicaragua becoming increasingly distinguishable from those of Costa Rica and Panama with time. Models entailing progressive arc magmatic enrichment are generally supported by the CAVAS record. Progressive enrichment of the oceanic CAVAS with time reflects changes in mantle wedge composition and decreased melting due to arc crust thickening, which was kick-started by the involvement of enriched plume mantle in the formation of the CAVAS. Progressive crustal thickening and associated changes in the sub-arc thermal regime resulted in decreasing degrees of partial melting over time, which allowed for progressive enrichment of the CAVAS and ultimately the production of continental-like crust in Panama and Costa Rica by ~16-10 Ma.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)653-686
Number of pages34
JournalInternational Geology Review
Volume58
Issue number6
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2016 Apr 25

Fingerprint

continental crust
island arc
rock
crust
crustal thickening
thermal regime
mantle plume
oceanic crust
partial melting
magmatism
fractionation
melting
trace element
mantle

Keywords

  • Caribbean
  • Central America
  • Continental crust
  • Galapagos Plume
  • Subduction
  • Tectonics
  • Volcanic arc

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Geology

Cite this

Arc magmatic evolution and the construction of continental crust at the Central American Volcanic Arc system. / Whattam, Scott A.; Stern, Robert J.

In: International Geology Review, Vol. 58, No. 6, 25.04.2016, p. 653-686.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{21e9c5b0cc414adb84edbbddd42595f2,
title = "Arc magmatic evolution and the construction of continental crust at the Central American Volcanic Arc system",
abstract = "Whether or not magmatic arcs evolve compositionally with time and the processes responsible remain controversial. Resolution of this question requires the reconstruction of arc geochemical evolution at the level of a discrete arc system. Here, we address this problem using the well-studied Central American Volcanic Arc System (CAVAS) as an example. Geochemical and isotopic data were compiled for 1031 samples of lavas and intrusive rocks from the ~1100 km-long segment of oceanic CAVAS (Panama, Costa Rica, Nicaragua) built on thickened oceanic crust over its 75 million year lifespan. We used available age constraints to subdivide this data set into six magmatic phases: 75-39 Ma (Phase I or PI); 35-16 Ma (PII); 16-6 Ma (PIII); 6-3 Ma (PIV); 5.9-0.01 Ma (PVa arc alkaline and PVb adakitic); and 2.6-0 Ma (PVI, Quaternary to modern magmatism, predominantly 蠐 1 Ma). To correct for magmatic fractionation, selected major and trace element abundances were linearly regressed to 55 wt.{\%} SiO2. The most striking observation is the overall evolution of the CAVAS to more incompatible element enriched and ultimately continental-like compositions with time, although magmatic evolution took on a more regional character in the youngest rocks, with magmatic rocks of Nicaragua becoming increasingly distinguishable from those of Costa Rica and Panama with time. Models entailing progressive arc magmatic enrichment are generally supported by the CAVAS record. Progressive enrichment of the oceanic CAVAS with time reflects changes in mantle wedge composition and decreased melting due to arc crust thickening, which was kick-started by the involvement of enriched plume mantle in the formation of the CAVAS. Progressive crustal thickening and associated changes in the sub-arc thermal regime resulted in decreasing degrees of partial melting over time, which allowed for progressive enrichment of the CAVAS and ultimately the production of continental-like crust in Panama and Costa Rica by ~16-10 Ma.",
keywords = "Caribbean, Central America, Continental crust, Galapagos Plume, Subduction, Tectonics, Volcanic arc",
author = "Whattam, {Scott A.} and Stern, {Robert J.}",
year = "2016",
month = "4",
day = "25",
doi = "10.1080/00206814.2015.1103668",
language = "English",
volume = "58",
pages = "653--686",
journal = "International Geology Review",
issn = "0020-6814",
publisher = "Bellwether Publishing, Ltd.",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Arc magmatic evolution and the construction of continental crust at the Central American Volcanic Arc system

AU - Whattam, Scott A.

AU - Stern, Robert J.

PY - 2016/4/25

Y1 - 2016/4/25

N2 - Whether or not magmatic arcs evolve compositionally with time and the processes responsible remain controversial. Resolution of this question requires the reconstruction of arc geochemical evolution at the level of a discrete arc system. Here, we address this problem using the well-studied Central American Volcanic Arc System (CAVAS) as an example. Geochemical and isotopic data were compiled for 1031 samples of lavas and intrusive rocks from the ~1100 km-long segment of oceanic CAVAS (Panama, Costa Rica, Nicaragua) built on thickened oceanic crust over its 75 million year lifespan. We used available age constraints to subdivide this data set into six magmatic phases: 75-39 Ma (Phase I or PI); 35-16 Ma (PII); 16-6 Ma (PIII); 6-3 Ma (PIV); 5.9-0.01 Ma (PVa arc alkaline and PVb adakitic); and 2.6-0 Ma (PVI, Quaternary to modern magmatism, predominantly 蠐 1 Ma). To correct for magmatic fractionation, selected major and trace element abundances were linearly regressed to 55 wt.% SiO2. The most striking observation is the overall evolution of the CAVAS to more incompatible element enriched and ultimately continental-like compositions with time, although magmatic evolution took on a more regional character in the youngest rocks, with magmatic rocks of Nicaragua becoming increasingly distinguishable from those of Costa Rica and Panama with time. Models entailing progressive arc magmatic enrichment are generally supported by the CAVAS record. Progressive enrichment of the oceanic CAVAS with time reflects changes in mantle wedge composition and decreased melting due to arc crust thickening, which was kick-started by the involvement of enriched plume mantle in the formation of the CAVAS. Progressive crustal thickening and associated changes in the sub-arc thermal regime resulted in decreasing degrees of partial melting over time, which allowed for progressive enrichment of the CAVAS and ultimately the production of continental-like crust in Panama and Costa Rica by ~16-10 Ma.

AB - Whether or not magmatic arcs evolve compositionally with time and the processes responsible remain controversial. Resolution of this question requires the reconstruction of arc geochemical evolution at the level of a discrete arc system. Here, we address this problem using the well-studied Central American Volcanic Arc System (CAVAS) as an example. Geochemical and isotopic data were compiled for 1031 samples of lavas and intrusive rocks from the ~1100 km-long segment of oceanic CAVAS (Panama, Costa Rica, Nicaragua) built on thickened oceanic crust over its 75 million year lifespan. We used available age constraints to subdivide this data set into six magmatic phases: 75-39 Ma (Phase I or PI); 35-16 Ma (PII); 16-6 Ma (PIII); 6-3 Ma (PIV); 5.9-0.01 Ma (PVa arc alkaline and PVb adakitic); and 2.6-0 Ma (PVI, Quaternary to modern magmatism, predominantly 蠐 1 Ma). To correct for magmatic fractionation, selected major and trace element abundances were linearly regressed to 55 wt.% SiO2. The most striking observation is the overall evolution of the CAVAS to more incompatible element enriched and ultimately continental-like compositions with time, although magmatic evolution took on a more regional character in the youngest rocks, with magmatic rocks of Nicaragua becoming increasingly distinguishable from those of Costa Rica and Panama with time. Models entailing progressive arc magmatic enrichment are generally supported by the CAVAS record. Progressive enrichment of the oceanic CAVAS with time reflects changes in mantle wedge composition and decreased melting due to arc crust thickening, which was kick-started by the involvement of enriched plume mantle in the formation of the CAVAS. Progressive crustal thickening and associated changes in the sub-arc thermal regime resulted in decreasing degrees of partial melting over time, which allowed for progressive enrichment of the CAVAS and ultimately the production of continental-like crust in Panama and Costa Rica by ~16-10 Ma.

KW - Caribbean

KW - Central America

KW - Continental crust

KW - Galapagos Plume

KW - Subduction

KW - Tectonics

KW - Volcanic arc

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84954074710&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84954074710&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/00206814.2015.1103668

DO - 10.1080/00206814.2015.1103668

M3 - Article

VL - 58

SP - 653

EP - 686

JO - International Geology Review

JF - International Geology Review

SN - 0020-6814

IS - 6

ER -