DDP controversy and the dilemma of h-sang seung's "landscript"

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Zaha Hadid's design of the DDP (2007-13) in Seoul has been criticized for its seeming disinterest in the site's sense of place. The most consistent critic against the design is H-Sang Seung (b. 1952), one of the participants in the 2007 competition for the project. For Seung, careful consideration of "the record and story of our lives…written on the land," which was to be theorized under the name "landscript" (2009), should have been the starting point of the present DDP. Though very cogent, however, his opinion cannot but encounter a dilemma in the fact that the futuristic DDP will also be established as one layer of the "landscript" on the site. In addition, his "landscript" theory, partly supported by Heidegger's concept of place, could be criticized based on criticism of Heidegger. For example, Neil Leach (1998)—after Jean-François Lyotard (1987)—sensed "a potential violence" and "the logic of exclusion" in the Heideggerian place. In the contemporary context of "the heterogeneous, open cosmopolis," Leach argues, we should pursue "cosmopolitan architectures" transcending "the rigid constraints of the genius loci." On the basis of Leach's argument, this paper aims for a critical re-reading of Seung's "landscript," revealing his dilemma in the DDP controversy.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)205-212
Number of pages8
JournalJournal of Asian Architecture and Building Engineering
Volume17
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2018 Jan 1

Fingerprint

critic
criticism
exclusion
violence
present
Martin Heidegger
Genius
Seoul
Locus
Rereading
Criticism
Sense of Place
Cosmopolis
Zaha Hadid
Names
Exclusion
Layer
Logic
Violence

Keywords

  • Criticism of Heidegger
  • DDP controversy
  • H-Sang Seung
  • Landscript
  • Place

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Civil and Structural Engineering
  • Architecture
  • Cultural Studies
  • Building and Construction
  • Arts and Humanities (miscellaneous)

Cite this

DDP controversy and the dilemma of h-sang seung's "landscript". / Kim, Hyon-Sob.

In: Journal of Asian Architecture and Building Engineering, Vol. 17, No. 2, 01.01.2018, p. 205-212.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{f539ec718fb048b9b2411128325973f1,
title = "DDP controversy and the dilemma of h-sang seung's {"}landscript{"}",
abstract = "Zaha Hadid's design of the DDP (2007-13) in Seoul has been criticized for its seeming disinterest in the site's sense of place. The most consistent critic against the design is H-Sang Seung (b. 1952), one of the participants in the 2007 competition for the project. For Seung, careful consideration of {"}the record and story of our lives…written on the land,{"} which was to be theorized under the name {"}landscript{"} (2009), should have been the starting point of the present DDP. Though very cogent, however, his opinion cannot but encounter a dilemma in the fact that the futuristic DDP will also be established as one layer of the {"}landscript{"} on the site. In addition, his {"}landscript{"} theory, partly supported by Heidegger's concept of place, could be criticized based on criticism of Heidegger. For example, Neil Leach (1998)—after Jean-Fran{\cc}ois Lyotard (1987)—sensed {"}a potential violence{"} and {"}the logic of exclusion{"} in the Heideggerian place. In the contemporary context of {"}the heterogeneous, open cosmopolis,{"} Leach argues, we should pursue {"}cosmopolitan architectures{"} transcending {"}the rigid constraints of the genius loci.{"} On the basis of Leach's argument, this paper aims for a critical re-reading of Seung's {"}landscript,{"} revealing his dilemma in the DDP controversy.",
keywords = "Criticism of Heidegger, DDP controversy, H-Sang Seung, Landscript, Place",
author = "Hyon-Sob Kim",
year = "2018",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.3130/jaabe.17.205",
language = "English",
volume = "17",
pages = "205--212",
journal = "Journal of Asian Architecture and Building Engineering",
issn = "1346-7581",
publisher = "Architectural Institute of Japan",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - DDP controversy and the dilemma of h-sang seung's "landscript"

AU - Kim, Hyon-Sob

PY - 2018/1/1

Y1 - 2018/1/1

N2 - Zaha Hadid's design of the DDP (2007-13) in Seoul has been criticized for its seeming disinterest in the site's sense of place. The most consistent critic against the design is H-Sang Seung (b. 1952), one of the participants in the 2007 competition for the project. For Seung, careful consideration of "the record and story of our lives…written on the land," which was to be theorized under the name "landscript" (2009), should have been the starting point of the present DDP. Though very cogent, however, his opinion cannot but encounter a dilemma in the fact that the futuristic DDP will also be established as one layer of the "landscript" on the site. In addition, his "landscript" theory, partly supported by Heidegger's concept of place, could be criticized based on criticism of Heidegger. For example, Neil Leach (1998)—after Jean-François Lyotard (1987)—sensed "a potential violence" and "the logic of exclusion" in the Heideggerian place. In the contemporary context of "the heterogeneous, open cosmopolis," Leach argues, we should pursue "cosmopolitan architectures" transcending "the rigid constraints of the genius loci." On the basis of Leach's argument, this paper aims for a critical re-reading of Seung's "landscript," revealing his dilemma in the DDP controversy.

AB - Zaha Hadid's design of the DDP (2007-13) in Seoul has been criticized for its seeming disinterest in the site's sense of place. The most consistent critic against the design is H-Sang Seung (b. 1952), one of the participants in the 2007 competition for the project. For Seung, careful consideration of "the record and story of our lives…written on the land," which was to be theorized under the name "landscript" (2009), should have been the starting point of the present DDP. Though very cogent, however, his opinion cannot but encounter a dilemma in the fact that the futuristic DDP will also be established as one layer of the "landscript" on the site. In addition, his "landscript" theory, partly supported by Heidegger's concept of place, could be criticized based on criticism of Heidegger. For example, Neil Leach (1998)—after Jean-François Lyotard (1987)—sensed "a potential violence" and "the logic of exclusion" in the Heideggerian place. In the contemporary context of "the heterogeneous, open cosmopolis," Leach argues, we should pursue "cosmopolitan architectures" transcending "the rigid constraints of the genius loci." On the basis of Leach's argument, this paper aims for a critical re-reading of Seung's "landscript," revealing his dilemma in the DDP controversy.

KW - Criticism of Heidegger

KW - DDP controversy

KW - H-Sang Seung

KW - Landscript

KW - Place

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85047017875&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85047017875&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.3130/jaabe.17.205

DO - 10.3130/jaabe.17.205

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85047017875

VL - 17

SP - 205

EP - 212

JO - Journal of Asian Architecture and Building Engineering

JF - Journal of Asian Architecture and Building Engineering

SN - 1346-7581

IS - 2

ER -