Estimates of crowding in long-term care: Comparing two approaches

Donna L. Algase, Cathy Antonakos, Elizabeth Beattie, Cynthia Beel-Bates, Jun-Ah Song

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objective: Because studies of crowding in long-term care settings are lacking, the authors sought to: (1) generate initial estimates of crowding in nursing homes and assisted living facilities; and (2) evaluate two operational approaches to its measurement. Background: Reactions to density and proximity are complex. Greater density intensifies people's reaction to a situation in the direction (positive or negative) that they would react if the situation were to occur under less dense conditions. People with dementia are especially reactive to the environment. Methods: Using a cross-sectional correlational design in nursing homes and assisted living facilities involving 185 participants, multiple observations (N = 6,455) of crowding and other environmental variables were made. Crowding, location, and sound were measured three times per observation; ambiance was measured once. Data analyses consisted of descriptive statistics, t-tests, and one-way analysis of variance. Results: Crowding estimates were higher for nursing homes and in dining and activity rooms. Crowding also varied across settings and locations by time of day. Overall, the interaction of location and time affected crowding significantly (N = 5,559, df [47,511], F = 105.69, p < .0001); effects were greater within location-by-hour than between location-by-hour, but the effect explained slightly less variance in Long-Term Care Crowding Index (LTC-CI) estimates (47.41%) than location alone. Crowding had small, direct, and highly significant correlations with sound and with the engaging subscale for ambiance; a similar, though inverse, correlation was seen with the soothing subscale for ambiance. Conclusions: Crowding fluctuates consistent with routine activities such as meals in long-term care settings. Furthermore, a relationship between crowding and other physical characteristics of the environment was found. The LTC-CI is likely to be more sensitive than simple people counts when seeking to evaluate the effects of crowding on the behavior of elders-particularly those with dementia-in long-term care settings. aging in place.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)61-74
Number of pages14
JournalHealth Environments Research and Design Journal
Volume4
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 2011 Dec 1

Fingerprint

Crowding
Long-Term Care
Assisted Living Facilities
Nursing Homes
Dementia
Independent Living
Meals
Analysis of Variance

Keywords

  • Geriatrics
  • Long-term care
  • Measures
  • Nursing
  • Observational methods

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health
  • Critical Care and Intensive Care Medicine

Cite this

Estimates of crowding in long-term care : Comparing two approaches. / Algase, Donna L.; Antonakos, Cathy; Beattie, Elizabeth; Beel-Bates, Cynthia; Song, Jun-Ah.

In: Health Environments Research and Design Journal, Vol. 4, No. 2, 01.12.2011, p. 61-74.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Algase, DL, Antonakos, C, Beattie, E, Beel-Bates, C & Song, J-A 2011, 'Estimates of crowding in long-term care: Comparing two approaches', Health Environments Research and Design Journal, vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 61-74.
Algase, Donna L. ; Antonakos, Cathy ; Beattie, Elizabeth ; Beel-Bates, Cynthia ; Song, Jun-Ah. / Estimates of crowding in long-term care : Comparing two approaches. In: Health Environments Research and Design Journal. 2011 ; Vol. 4, No. 2. pp. 61-74.
@article{2cb7067d208b4baf87e0bc487ef9fe5a,
title = "Estimates of crowding in long-term care: Comparing two approaches",
abstract = "Objective: Because studies of crowding in long-term care settings are lacking, the authors sought to: (1) generate initial estimates of crowding in nursing homes and assisted living facilities; and (2) evaluate two operational approaches to its measurement. Background: Reactions to density and proximity are complex. Greater density intensifies people's reaction to a situation in the direction (positive or negative) that they would react if the situation were to occur under less dense conditions. People with dementia are especially reactive to the environment. Methods: Using a cross-sectional correlational design in nursing homes and assisted living facilities involving 185 participants, multiple observations (N = 6,455) of crowding and other environmental variables were made. Crowding, location, and sound were measured three times per observation; ambiance was measured once. Data analyses consisted of descriptive statistics, t-tests, and one-way analysis of variance. Results: Crowding estimates were higher for nursing homes and in dining and activity rooms. Crowding also varied across settings and locations by time of day. Overall, the interaction of location and time affected crowding significantly (N = 5,559, df [47,511], F = 105.69, p < .0001); effects were greater within location-by-hour than between location-by-hour, but the effect explained slightly less variance in Long-Term Care Crowding Index (LTC-CI) estimates (47.41{\%}) than location alone. Crowding had small, direct, and highly significant correlations with sound and with the engaging subscale for ambiance; a similar, though inverse, correlation was seen with the soothing subscale for ambiance. Conclusions: Crowding fluctuates consistent with routine activities such as meals in long-term care settings. Furthermore, a relationship between crowding and other physical characteristics of the environment was found. The LTC-CI is likely to be more sensitive than simple people counts when seeking to evaluate the effects of crowding on the behavior of elders-particularly those with dementia-in long-term care settings. aging in place.",
keywords = "Geriatrics, Long-term care, Measures, Nursing, Observational methods",
author = "Algase, {Donna L.} and Cathy Antonakos and Elizabeth Beattie and Cynthia Beel-Bates and Jun-Ah Song",
year = "2011",
month = "12",
day = "1",
language = "English",
volume = "4",
pages = "61--74",
journal = "HERD",
issn = "1937-5867",
publisher = "Vendome Group",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Estimates of crowding in long-term care

T2 - Comparing two approaches

AU - Algase, Donna L.

AU - Antonakos, Cathy

AU - Beattie, Elizabeth

AU - Beel-Bates, Cynthia

AU - Song, Jun-Ah

PY - 2011/12/1

Y1 - 2011/12/1

N2 - Objective: Because studies of crowding in long-term care settings are lacking, the authors sought to: (1) generate initial estimates of crowding in nursing homes and assisted living facilities; and (2) evaluate two operational approaches to its measurement. Background: Reactions to density and proximity are complex. Greater density intensifies people's reaction to a situation in the direction (positive or negative) that they would react if the situation were to occur under less dense conditions. People with dementia are especially reactive to the environment. Methods: Using a cross-sectional correlational design in nursing homes and assisted living facilities involving 185 participants, multiple observations (N = 6,455) of crowding and other environmental variables were made. Crowding, location, and sound were measured three times per observation; ambiance was measured once. Data analyses consisted of descriptive statistics, t-tests, and one-way analysis of variance. Results: Crowding estimates were higher for nursing homes and in dining and activity rooms. Crowding also varied across settings and locations by time of day. Overall, the interaction of location and time affected crowding significantly (N = 5,559, df [47,511], F = 105.69, p < .0001); effects were greater within location-by-hour than between location-by-hour, but the effect explained slightly less variance in Long-Term Care Crowding Index (LTC-CI) estimates (47.41%) than location alone. Crowding had small, direct, and highly significant correlations with sound and with the engaging subscale for ambiance; a similar, though inverse, correlation was seen with the soothing subscale for ambiance. Conclusions: Crowding fluctuates consistent with routine activities such as meals in long-term care settings. Furthermore, a relationship between crowding and other physical characteristics of the environment was found. The LTC-CI is likely to be more sensitive than simple people counts when seeking to evaluate the effects of crowding on the behavior of elders-particularly those with dementia-in long-term care settings. aging in place.

AB - Objective: Because studies of crowding in long-term care settings are lacking, the authors sought to: (1) generate initial estimates of crowding in nursing homes and assisted living facilities; and (2) evaluate two operational approaches to its measurement. Background: Reactions to density and proximity are complex. Greater density intensifies people's reaction to a situation in the direction (positive or negative) that they would react if the situation were to occur under less dense conditions. People with dementia are especially reactive to the environment. Methods: Using a cross-sectional correlational design in nursing homes and assisted living facilities involving 185 participants, multiple observations (N = 6,455) of crowding and other environmental variables were made. Crowding, location, and sound were measured three times per observation; ambiance was measured once. Data analyses consisted of descriptive statistics, t-tests, and one-way analysis of variance. Results: Crowding estimates were higher for nursing homes and in dining and activity rooms. Crowding also varied across settings and locations by time of day. Overall, the interaction of location and time affected crowding significantly (N = 5,559, df [47,511], F = 105.69, p < .0001); effects were greater within location-by-hour than between location-by-hour, but the effect explained slightly less variance in Long-Term Care Crowding Index (LTC-CI) estimates (47.41%) than location alone. Crowding had small, direct, and highly significant correlations with sound and with the engaging subscale for ambiance; a similar, though inverse, correlation was seen with the soothing subscale for ambiance. Conclusions: Crowding fluctuates consistent with routine activities such as meals in long-term care settings. Furthermore, a relationship between crowding and other physical characteristics of the environment was found. The LTC-CI is likely to be more sensitive than simple people counts when seeking to evaluate the effects of crowding on the behavior of elders-particularly those with dementia-in long-term care settings. aging in place.

KW - Geriatrics

KW - Long-term care

KW - Measures

KW - Nursing

KW - Observational methods

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=79958831857&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=79958831857&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 21465435

AN - SCOPUS:79958831857

VL - 4

SP - 61

EP - 74

JO - HERD

JF - HERD

SN - 1937-5867

IS - 2

ER -