Identifying Granger causal relationships between neural power dynamics and variables of interest

Irene Winkler, Stefan Haufe, Anne K. Porbadnigk, Klaus Muller, Sven Dähne

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

8 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Power modulations of oscillations in electro- and magnetoencephalographic (EEG/MEG) signals have been linked to a wide range of brain functions. To date, most of the evidence is obtained by correlating bandpower fluctuations to specific target variables such as reaction times or task ratings, while the causal links between oscillatory activity and behavior remain less clear. Here, we propose to identify causal relationships by the statistical concept of Granger causality, and we investigate which methods are bests suited to reveal Granger causal links between the power of brain oscillations and experimental variables.As an alternative to testing such causal links on the sensor level, we propose to linearly combine the information contained in each sensor in order to create virtual channels, corresponding to estimates of underlying brain oscillations, the Granger-causal relations of which may be assessed. Such linear combinations of sensor can be given by source separation methods such as, for example, Independent Component Analysis (ICA) or by the recently developed Source Power Correlation (SPoC) method.Here we compare Granger causal analysis on power dynamics obtained from i) sensor directly, ii) spatial filtering methods that do not optimize for Granger causality (ICA and SPoC), and iii) a method that directly optimizes spatial filters to extract sources the power dynamics of which maximally Granger causes a given target variable. We refer to this method as Granger Causal Power Analysis (GrangerCPA).Using both simulated and real EEG recordings, we find that computing Granger causality on channel-wise spectral power suffers from a poor signal-to-noise ratio due to volume conduction, while all three multivariate approaches alleviate this issue. In real EEG recordings from subjects performing self-paced foot movements, all three multivariate methods identify neural oscillations with motor-related patterns at a similar performance level. In an auditory perception task, the application of GrangerCPA reveals significant Granger-causal links between alpha oscillations and reaction times in more subjects compared to conventional methods.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)489-504
Number of pages16
JournalNeuroImage
Volume111
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2015 May 1

Fingerprint

Electric Power Supplies
Causality
Electroencephalography
Brain
Auditory Perception
Power (Psychology)
Signal-To-Noise Ratio
Foot

Keywords

  • EEG
  • Granger causality
  • MEG
  • Oscillations

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Cognitive Neuroscience
  • Neurology

Cite this

Identifying Granger causal relationships between neural power dynamics and variables of interest. / Winkler, Irene; Haufe, Stefan; Porbadnigk, Anne K.; Muller, Klaus; Dähne, Sven.

In: NeuroImage, Vol. 111, 01.05.2015, p. 489-504.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Winkler, Irene ; Haufe, Stefan ; Porbadnigk, Anne K. ; Muller, Klaus ; Dähne, Sven. / Identifying Granger causal relationships between neural power dynamics and variables of interest. In: NeuroImage. 2015 ; Vol. 111. pp. 489-504.
@article{233edbc68a644c7e9b49a6887e13dcc6,
title = "Identifying Granger causal relationships between neural power dynamics and variables of interest",
abstract = "Power modulations of oscillations in electro- and magnetoencephalographic (EEG/MEG) signals have been linked to a wide range of brain functions. To date, most of the evidence is obtained by correlating bandpower fluctuations to specific target variables such as reaction times or task ratings, while the causal links between oscillatory activity and behavior remain less clear. Here, we propose to identify causal relationships by the statistical concept of Granger causality, and we investigate which methods are bests suited to reveal Granger causal links between the power of brain oscillations and experimental variables.As an alternative to testing such causal links on the sensor level, we propose to linearly combine the information contained in each sensor in order to create virtual channels, corresponding to estimates of underlying brain oscillations, the Granger-causal relations of which may be assessed. Such linear combinations of sensor can be given by source separation methods such as, for example, Independent Component Analysis (ICA) or by the recently developed Source Power Correlation (SPoC) method.Here we compare Granger causal analysis on power dynamics obtained from i) sensor directly, ii) spatial filtering methods that do not optimize for Granger causality (ICA and SPoC), and iii) a method that directly optimizes spatial filters to extract sources the power dynamics of which maximally Granger causes a given target variable. We refer to this method as Granger Causal Power Analysis (GrangerCPA).Using both simulated and real EEG recordings, we find that computing Granger causality on channel-wise spectral power suffers from a poor signal-to-noise ratio due to volume conduction, while all three multivariate approaches alleviate this issue. In real EEG recordings from subjects performing self-paced foot movements, all three multivariate methods identify neural oscillations with motor-related patterns at a similar performance level. In an auditory perception task, the application of GrangerCPA reveals significant Granger-causal links between alpha oscillations and reaction times in more subjects compared to conventional methods.",
keywords = "EEG, Granger causality, MEG, Oscillations",
author = "Irene Winkler and Stefan Haufe and Porbadnigk, {Anne K.} and Klaus Muller and Sven D{\"a}hne",
year = "2015",
month = "5",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.neuroimage.2014.12.059",
language = "English",
volume = "111",
pages = "489--504",
journal = "NeuroImage",
issn = "1053-8119",
publisher = "Academic Press Inc.",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Identifying Granger causal relationships between neural power dynamics and variables of interest

AU - Winkler, Irene

AU - Haufe, Stefan

AU - Porbadnigk, Anne K.

AU - Muller, Klaus

AU - Dähne, Sven

PY - 2015/5/1

Y1 - 2015/5/1

N2 - Power modulations of oscillations in electro- and magnetoencephalographic (EEG/MEG) signals have been linked to a wide range of brain functions. To date, most of the evidence is obtained by correlating bandpower fluctuations to specific target variables such as reaction times or task ratings, while the causal links between oscillatory activity and behavior remain less clear. Here, we propose to identify causal relationships by the statistical concept of Granger causality, and we investigate which methods are bests suited to reveal Granger causal links between the power of brain oscillations and experimental variables.As an alternative to testing such causal links on the sensor level, we propose to linearly combine the information contained in each sensor in order to create virtual channels, corresponding to estimates of underlying brain oscillations, the Granger-causal relations of which may be assessed. Such linear combinations of sensor can be given by source separation methods such as, for example, Independent Component Analysis (ICA) or by the recently developed Source Power Correlation (SPoC) method.Here we compare Granger causal analysis on power dynamics obtained from i) sensor directly, ii) spatial filtering methods that do not optimize for Granger causality (ICA and SPoC), and iii) a method that directly optimizes spatial filters to extract sources the power dynamics of which maximally Granger causes a given target variable. We refer to this method as Granger Causal Power Analysis (GrangerCPA).Using both simulated and real EEG recordings, we find that computing Granger causality on channel-wise spectral power suffers from a poor signal-to-noise ratio due to volume conduction, while all three multivariate approaches alleviate this issue. In real EEG recordings from subjects performing self-paced foot movements, all three multivariate methods identify neural oscillations with motor-related patterns at a similar performance level. In an auditory perception task, the application of GrangerCPA reveals significant Granger-causal links between alpha oscillations and reaction times in more subjects compared to conventional methods.

AB - Power modulations of oscillations in electro- and magnetoencephalographic (EEG/MEG) signals have been linked to a wide range of brain functions. To date, most of the evidence is obtained by correlating bandpower fluctuations to specific target variables such as reaction times or task ratings, while the causal links between oscillatory activity and behavior remain less clear. Here, we propose to identify causal relationships by the statistical concept of Granger causality, and we investigate which methods are bests suited to reveal Granger causal links between the power of brain oscillations and experimental variables.As an alternative to testing such causal links on the sensor level, we propose to linearly combine the information contained in each sensor in order to create virtual channels, corresponding to estimates of underlying brain oscillations, the Granger-causal relations of which may be assessed. Such linear combinations of sensor can be given by source separation methods such as, for example, Independent Component Analysis (ICA) or by the recently developed Source Power Correlation (SPoC) method.Here we compare Granger causal analysis on power dynamics obtained from i) sensor directly, ii) spatial filtering methods that do not optimize for Granger causality (ICA and SPoC), and iii) a method that directly optimizes spatial filters to extract sources the power dynamics of which maximally Granger causes a given target variable. We refer to this method as Granger Causal Power Analysis (GrangerCPA).Using both simulated and real EEG recordings, we find that computing Granger causality on channel-wise spectral power suffers from a poor signal-to-noise ratio due to volume conduction, while all three multivariate approaches alleviate this issue. In real EEG recordings from subjects performing self-paced foot movements, all three multivariate methods identify neural oscillations with motor-related patterns at a similar performance level. In an auditory perception task, the application of GrangerCPA reveals significant Granger-causal links between alpha oscillations and reaction times in more subjects compared to conventional methods.

KW - EEG

KW - Granger causality

KW - MEG

KW - Oscillations

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84939972789&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84939972789&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2014.12.059

DO - 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2014.12.059

M3 - Article

C2 - 25554431

AN - SCOPUS:84939972789

VL - 111

SP - 489

EP - 504

JO - NeuroImage

JF - NeuroImage

SN - 1053-8119

ER -