Master curve characterization of irradiation embrittlement using standard and 1/3-sized precracked Charpy specimens

Bong Sang Lee, Won J. Yang, Moo Young Huh, Se Hwan Chi, Jun H. Hong

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Cleavage initiation fracture toughness (K JC) tests have been performed in the transition temperature ranges of five different heats of reactor pressure vessel steels. The main purpose of this study is to investigate the applicability of the ASTM Standard Test Method for Determination of Reference Temperature, T o, for Ferritic Steels in the Transition Range (E1921-97) to small specimens available in normal surveillance capsules. Precracked Charpy-type specimens with the standard size (10×10×55 mm, PCVN) and 1/3-size (3.3×3.3×18.3 mm, 1/3-PCVN) are mainly investigated. Results from more than 300 fracture toughness test data are presented including 120 unirradiated PCVN specimens and 100 unirradiated 1/3-PCVN specimens in addition to some CT specimen data and two sets of irradiated PCVN data. The test materials are the IAEA reference steels, so-called JRQ and JFL, and three Korean SA508-3 forging steels that were made by different refining processes. JRQ and a Korean steel, SKA-1, are also evaluated after neutron irradiation by PCVN specimens as well as Charpy impact tests. Fracture toughness data showed that the master curve and its probabilistic bound lines represent the population of the test data measured from different materials and specimens with good accuracy. However, there are still the effects of specimen geometry and size on the measured To values. These effects seem to be more significant in microscopically less homogeneous materials. Smaller bend type specimens may give slightly less conservative results than the larger CT type specimens. One of the important findings is that ultra small 1/3-PCVN specimens are also valuable as the standard size PCVN specimens for determining reference temperatures since the differences are rather systematic and predictable. The T 28J correlation, based on the PCVN data only, works well for the current data sets including irradiated materials.

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationInstitution of Chemical Engineers Symposium Series
Pages55-67
Number of pages13
Edition148
Publication statusPublished - 2000
Externally publishedYes
EventHazards XVI Analysing the Past, Planning the Future - Manchester, United Kingdom
Duration: 2001 Nov 62001 Nov 8

Other

OtherHazards XVI Analysing the Past, Planning the Future
CountryUnited Kingdom
CityManchester
Period01/11/601/11/8

Fingerprint

Embrittlement
Steel
Irradiation
Fracture toughness
Neutron irradiation
Ferritic steel
Steel structures
Forging
Superconducting transition temperature
Refining
Capsules
Temperature
Geometry

Keywords

  • Fracture toughness
  • Irradiation embrittlement
  • Master curve
  • PCVN
  • Precracked Charpy
  • Reference temperature
  • T

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Chemical Engineering(all)

Cite this

Lee, B. S., Yang, W. J., Huh, M. Y., Chi, S. H., & Hong, J. H. (2000). Master curve characterization of irradiation embrittlement using standard and 1/3-sized precracked Charpy specimens. In Institution of Chemical Engineers Symposium Series (148 ed., pp. 55-67)

Master curve characterization of irradiation embrittlement using standard and 1/3-sized precracked Charpy specimens. / Lee, Bong Sang; Yang, Won J.; Huh, Moo Young; Chi, Se Hwan; Hong, Jun H.

Institution of Chemical Engineers Symposium Series. 148. ed. 2000. p. 55-67.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Lee, BS, Yang, WJ, Huh, MY, Chi, SH & Hong, JH 2000, Master curve characterization of irradiation embrittlement using standard and 1/3-sized precracked Charpy specimens. in Institution of Chemical Engineers Symposium Series. 148 edn, pp. 55-67, Hazards XVI Analysing the Past, Planning the Future, Manchester, United Kingdom, 01/11/6.
Lee BS, Yang WJ, Huh MY, Chi SH, Hong JH. Master curve characterization of irradiation embrittlement using standard and 1/3-sized precracked Charpy specimens. In Institution of Chemical Engineers Symposium Series. 148 ed. 2000. p. 55-67
Lee, Bong Sang ; Yang, Won J. ; Huh, Moo Young ; Chi, Se Hwan ; Hong, Jun H. / Master curve characterization of irradiation embrittlement using standard and 1/3-sized precracked Charpy specimens. Institution of Chemical Engineers Symposium Series. 148. ed. 2000. pp. 55-67
@inproceedings{ce2ac0311061471fb09a5f1ea73f10ef,
title = "Master curve characterization of irradiation embrittlement using standard and 1/3-sized precracked Charpy specimens",
abstract = "Cleavage initiation fracture toughness (K JC) tests have been performed in the transition temperature ranges of five different heats of reactor pressure vessel steels. The main purpose of this study is to investigate the applicability of the ASTM Standard Test Method for Determination of Reference Temperature, T o, for Ferritic Steels in the Transition Range (E1921-97) to small specimens available in normal surveillance capsules. Precracked Charpy-type specimens with the standard size (10×10×55 mm, PCVN) and 1/3-size (3.3×3.3×18.3 mm, 1/3-PCVN) are mainly investigated. Results from more than 300 fracture toughness test data are presented including 120 unirradiated PCVN specimens and 100 unirradiated 1/3-PCVN specimens in addition to some CT specimen data and two sets of irradiated PCVN data. The test materials are the IAEA reference steels, so-called JRQ and JFL, and three Korean SA508-3 forging steels that were made by different refining processes. JRQ and a Korean steel, SKA-1, are also evaluated after neutron irradiation by PCVN specimens as well as Charpy impact tests. Fracture toughness data showed that the master curve and its probabilistic bound lines represent the population of the test data measured from different materials and specimens with good accuracy. However, there are still the effects of specimen geometry and size on the measured To values. These effects seem to be more significant in microscopically less homogeneous materials. Smaller bend type specimens may give slightly less conservative results than the larger CT type specimens. One of the important findings is that ultra small 1/3-PCVN specimens are also valuable as the standard size PCVN specimens for determining reference temperatures since the differences are rather systematic and predictable. The T 28J correlation, based on the PCVN data only, works well for the current data sets including irradiated materials.",
keywords = "Fracture toughness, Irradiation embrittlement, Master curve, PCVN, Precracked Charpy, Reference temperature, T",
author = "Lee, {Bong Sang} and Yang, {Won J.} and Huh, {Moo Young} and Chi, {Se Hwan} and Hong, {Jun H.}",
year = "2000",
language = "English",
pages = "55--67",
booktitle = "Institution of Chemical Engineers Symposium Series",
edition = "148",

}

TY - GEN

T1 - Master curve characterization of irradiation embrittlement using standard and 1/3-sized precracked Charpy specimens

AU - Lee, Bong Sang

AU - Yang, Won J.

AU - Huh, Moo Young

AU - Chi, Se Hwan

AU - Hong, Jun H.

PY - 2000

Y1 - 2000

N2 - Cleavage initiation fracture toughness (K JC) tests have been performed in the transition temperature ranges of five different heats of reactor pressure vessel steels. The main purpose of this study is to investigate the applicability of the ASTM Standard Test Method for Determination of Reference Temperature, T o, for Ferritic Steels in the Transition Range (E1921-97) to small specimens available in normal surveillance capsules. Precracked Charpy-type specimens with the standard size (10×10×55 mm, PCVN) and 1/3-size (3.3×3.3×18.3 mm, 1/3-PCVN) are mainly investigated. Results from more than 300 fracture toughness test data are presented including 120 unirradiated PCVN specimens and 100 unirradiated 1/3-PCVN specimens in addition to some CT specimen data and two sets of irradiated PCVN data. The test materials are the IAEA reference steels, so-called JRQ and JFL, and three Korean SA508-3 forging steels that were made by different refining processes. JRQ and a Korean steel, SKA-1, are also evaluated after neutron irradiation by PCVN specimens as well as Charpy impact tests. Fracture toughness data showed that the master curve and its probabilistic bound lines represent the population of the test data measured from different materials and specimens with good accuracy. However, there are still the effects of specimen geometry and size on the measured To values. These effects seem to be more significant in microscopically less homogeneous materials. Smaller bend type specimens may give slightly less conservative results than the larger CT type specimens. One of the important findings is that ultra small 1/3-PCVN specimens are also valuable as the standard size PCVN specimens for determining reference temperatures since the differences are rather systematic and predictable. The T 28J correlation, based on the PCVN data only, works well for the current data sets including irradiated materials.

AB - Cleavage initiation fracture toughness (K JC) tests have been performed in the transition temperature ranges of five different heats of reactor pressure vessel steels. The main purpose of this study is to investigate the applicability of the ASTM Standard Test Method for Determination of Reference Temperature, T o, for Ferritic Steels in the Transition Range (E1921-97) to small specimens available in normal surveillance capsules. Precracked Charpy-type specimens with the standard size (10×10×55 mm, PCVN) and 1/3-size (3.3×3.3×18.3 mm, 1/3-PCVN) are mainly investigated. Results from more than 300 fracture toughness test data are presented including 120 unirradiated PCVN specimens and 100 unirradiated 1/3-PCVN specimens in addition to some CT specimen data and two sets of irradiated PCVN data. The test materials are the IAEA reference steels, so-called JRQ and JFL, and three Korean SA508-3 forging steels that were made by different refining processes. JRQ and a Korean steel, SKA-1, are also evaluated after neutron irradiation by PCVN specimens as well as Charpy impact tests. Fracture toughness data showed that the master curve and its probabilistic bound lines represent the population of the test data measured from different materials and specimens with good accuracy. However, there are still the effects of specimen geometry and size on the measured To values. These effects seem to be more significant in microscopically less homogeneous materials. Smaller bend type specimens may give slightly less conservative results than the larger CT type specimens. One of the important findings is that ultra small 1/3-PCVN specimens are also valuable as the standard size PCVN specimens for determining reference temperatures since the differences are rather systematic and predictable. The T 28J correlation, based on the PCVN data only, works well for the current data sets including irradiated materials.

KW - Fracture toughness

KW - Irradiation embrittlement

KW - Master curve

KW - PCVN

KW - Precracked Charpy

KW - Reference temperature

KW - T

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0034461779&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0034461779&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Conference contribution

SP - 55

EP - 67

BT - Institution of Chemical Engineers Symposium Series

ER -