Multicriteria Optimization Model to Generate on-DEM Optimal Channel Networks

Simone Bizzi, Andrea Cominola, Emanuele Mason, Andrea Castelletti, Kyungrock Paik

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The theory of optimal channel networks (OCNs) explains the existence of self-similarities in river networks by multiple optimality principles, namely, (i) the minimum energy expenditure in any link, (ii) the equal energy expenditure per unit area of channel anywhere, and (iii) the minimum total energy expenditure (TEE). These principles have been used to generate OCNs from 2-D networks. The existing notion of OCN considers the concavity of river longitudinal profiles as a priori condition. Attempts to generate OCNs starting from a random 3-D digital elevation model (DEM) and minimizing solely TEE have failed to reproduce concave profiles. Yet alternative approaches can be devised from the three optimality principles, for instance, focusing on the local energy expenditure (LEE). In this paper, we propose a Multiobjective modeling framework for Riverscape Exploration (MoRE) via simultaneous optimization of multiple OCN criteria. MoRE adopts a multiobjective evolutionary algorithm and radial basis functions to efficiently guide DEM elevation variations required to shape 3-D OCNs. By minimizing both TEE and the variance in LEE, MoRE successfully reproduces realistic on-DEM, OCN-based riverscapes, for the first time. Simulated networks possess scaling laws of upstream area and length and river longitudinal profile resembling those of real river networks. The profile concavity of generated on-DEM OCNs emerges as a consequence of the minimization of TEE constrained to the equalization of LEE. Minimizing TEE under this condition generates networks that possess specific patterns of LEE, where the scaling of slope with basin area resembles the patterns observed in real river networks.

Original languageEnglish
JournalWater Resources Research
DOIs
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 2018 Jan 1

Fingerprint

digital elevation model
expenditure
energy
river
modeling

Keywords

  • digital elevation model
  • landscape evolution
  • optimal channel network
  • optimization
  • profile concavity
  • self-similarity

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Water Science and Technology

Cite this

Multicriteria Optimization Model to Generate on-DEM Optimal Channel Networks. / Bizzi, Simone; Cominola, Andrea; Mason, Emanuele; Castelletti, Andrea; Paik, Kyungrock.

In: Water Resources Research, 01.01.2018.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Bizzi, Simone ; Cominola, Andrea ; Mason, Emanuele ; Castelletti, Andrea ; Paik, Kyungrock. / Multicriteria Optimization Model to Generate on-DEM Optimal Channel Networks. In: Water Resources Research. 2018.
@article{f953623a90f545ffb5088f27d14262d0,
title = "Multicriteria Optimization Model to Generate on-DEM Optimal Channel Networks",
abstract = "The theory of optimal channel networks (OCNs) explains the existence of self-similarities in river networks by multiple optimality principles, namely, (i) the minimum energy expenditure in any link, (ii) the equal energy expenditure per unit area of channel anywhere, and (iii) the minimum total energy expenditure (TEE). These principles have been used to generate OCNs from 2-D networks. The existing notion of OCN considers the concavity of river longitudinal profiles as a priori condition. Attempts to generate OCNs starting from a random 3-D digital elevation model (DEM) and minimizing solely TEE have failed to reproduce concave profiles. Yet alternative approaches can be devised from the three optimality principles, for instance, focusing on the local energy expenditure (LEE). In this paper, we propose a Multiobjective modeling framework for Riverscape Exploration (MoRE) via simultaneous optimization of multiple OCN criteria. MoRE adopts a multiobjective evolutionary algorithm and radial basis functions to efficiently guide DEM elevation variations required to shape 3-D OCNs. By minimizing both TEE and the variance in LEE, MoRE successfully reproduces realistic on-DEM, OCN-based riverscapes, for the first time. Simulated networks possess scaling laws of upstream area and length and river longitudinal profile resembling those of real river networks. The profile concavity of generated on-DEM OCNs emerges as a consequence of the minimization of TEE constrained to the equalization of LEE. Minimizing TEE under this condition generates networks that possess specific patterns of LEE, where the scaling of slope with basin area resembles the patterns observed in real river networks.",
keywords = "digital elevation model, landscape evolution, optimal channel network, optimization, profile concavity, self-similarity",
author = "Simone Bizzi and Andrea Cominola and Emanuele Mason and Andrea Castelletti and Kyungrock Paik",
year = "2018",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1029/2018WR022977",
language = "English",
journal = "Water Resources Research",
issn = "0043-1397",
publisher = "American Geophysical Union",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Multicriteria Optimization Model to Generate on-DEM Optimal Channel Networks

AU - Bizzi, Simone

AU - Cominola, Andrea

AU - Mason, Emanuele

AU - Castelletti, Andrea

AU - Paik, Kyungrock

PY - 2018/1/1

Y1 - 2018/1/1

N2 - The theory of optimal channel networks (OCNs) explains the existence of self-similarities in river networks by multiple optimality principles, namely, (i) the minimum energy expenditure in any link, (ii) the equal energy expenditure per unit area of channel anywhere, and (iii) the minimum total energy expenditure (TEE). These principles have been used to generate OCNs from 2-D networks. The existing notion of OCN considers the concavity of river longitudinal profiles as a priori condition. Attempts to generate OCNs starting from a random 3-D digital elevation model (DEM) and minimizing solely TEE have failed to reproduce concave profiles. Yet alternative approaches can be devised from the three optimality principles, for instance, focusing on the local energy expenditure (LEE). In this paper, we propose a Multiobjective modeling framework for Riverscape Exploration (MoRE) via simultaneous optimization of multiple OCN criteria. MoRE adopts a multiobjective evolutionary algorithm and radial basis functions to efficiently guide DEM elevation variations required to shape 3-D OCNs. By minimizing both TEE and the variance in LEE, MoRE successfully reproduces realistic on-DEM, OCN-based riverscapes, for the first time. Simulated networks possess scaling laws of upstream area and length and river longitudinal profile resembling those of real river networks. The profile concavity of generated on-DEM OCNs emerges as a consequence of the minimization of TEE constrained to the equalization of LEE. Minimizing TEE under this condition generates networks that possess specific patterns of LEE, where the scaling of slope with basin area resembles the patterns observed in real river networks.

AB - The theory of optimal channel networks (OCNs) explains the existence of self-similarities in river networks by multiple optimality principles, namely, (i) the minimum energy expenditure in any link, (ii) the equal energy expenditure per unit area of channel anywhere, and (iii) the minimum total energy expenditure (TEE). These principles have been used to generate OCNs from 2-D networks. The existing notion of OCN considers the concavity of river longitudinal profiles as a priori condition. Attempts to generate OCNs starting from a random 3-D digital elevation model (DEM) and minimizing solely TEE have failed to reproduce concave profiles. Yet alternative approaches can be devised from the three optimality principles, for instance, focusing on the local energy expenditure (LEE). In this paper, we propose a Multiobjective modeling framework for Riverscape Exploration (MoRE) via simultaneous optimization of multiple OCN criteria. MoRE adopts a multiobjective evolutionary algorithm and radial basis functions to efficiently guide DEM elevation variations required to shape 3-D OCNs. By minimizing both TEE and the variance in LEE, MoRE successfully reproduces realistic on-DEM, OCN-based riverscapes, for the first time. Simulated networks possess scaling laws of upstream area and length and river longitudinal profile resembling those of real river networks. The profile concavity of generated on-DEM OCNs emerges as a consequence of the minimization of TEE constrained to the equalization of LEE. Minimizing TEE under this condition generates networks that possess specific patterns of LEE, where the scaling of slope with basin area resembles the patterns observed in real river networks.

KW - digital elevation model

KW - landscape evolution

KW - optimal channel network

KW - optimization

KW - profile concavity

KW - self-similarity

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85052433614&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85052433614&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1029/2018WR022977

DO - 10.1029/2018WR022977

M3 - Article

JO - Water Resources Research

JF - Water Resources Research

SN - 0043-1397

ER -