Reliability of coronal curvature measures in premature scoliosis: Comparison of 4 methods using inverted digital luminescence radiography

Jae-Young Hong, Jin Ho Hwang, Seung-Woo Suh, Jae Hyuk Yang, Jung Ryeol Kim, Yoon Gwang Bae

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Study Design. Observational study with 4 examiners. Objective. To improve the reproducibility and reliability of coronal curvature measurements. Summary of Background Data. Several different methods have been developed to measure coronal curvature. Inverted digital luminescence radiography may be an additional technique to improve the reliability of measurement methods. Methods. A total of 114 whole spine posterior-Anterior radiographs were collected to compare the reliability of 4 measurement methods used in early onset scoliosis. Each radiograph was measured twice by each of 4 examiners using 4 measurement methods with normal and inversion views. Data were analyzed to determine inter-And intraobserver reliabilities. Results. For all 4 methods, the overall intraobserver ICCs were greater than 0.926 and the interobserver ICCs were greater than 0.902, indicating excellent reliability. When intraobserver reliability was assessed in relation to scoliosis severity ( <20°, 20°-40°, and > 40°), the ICCs were higher for greater degrees of curvature; nonetheless, these values were in the excellent range for all methods and were higher for inversion (>0.908) than normal (>0.838) radiographs. For interobserver comparisons, the ICCs were better for the pedicle method (normal: >0.795, inversion: >0.831) than for the other methods (normal: >0.532, inversion: >0.590), with inverted digital luminescence radiography showing the higher ICCs. Conclusion. Inversion radiographs showed high reliability and may increase reliability in cases of less deformed spines. In addition, the pedicle method led to higher ICCs for all measurements regardless of severity, especially on inversion radiographs.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)E701-E712
JournalSpine
Volume40
Issue number12
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2015

Fingerprint

Radiographic Image Enhancement
Scoliosis
Luminescence
Spine
Observational Studies

Keywords

  • Intraclass correlation coeffi cient
  • Inverted digital luminescence radiograph
  • Pedicle method
  • Reliability analysis

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Clinical Neurology
  • Orthopedics and Sports Medicine

Cite this

Reliability of coronal curvature measures in premature scoliosis : Comparison of 4 methods using inverted digital luminescence radiography. / Hong, Jae-Young; Hwang, Jin Ho; Suh, Seung-Woo; Yang, Jae Hyuk; Kim, Jung Ryeol; Bae, Yoon Gwang.

In: Spine, Vol. 40, No. 12, 2015, p. E701-E712.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Hong, Jae-Young ; Hwang, Jin Ho ; Suh, Seung-Woo ; Yang, Jae Hyuk ; Kim, Jung Ryeol ; Bae, Yoon Gwang. / Reliability of coronal curvature measures in premature scoliosis : Comparison of 4 methods using inverted digital luminescence radiography. In: Spine. 2015 ; Vol. 40, No. 12. pp. E701-E712.
@article{d5c8c9777531460ba66fde4465f82260,
title = "Reliability of coronal curvature measures in premature scoliosis: Comparison of 4 methods using inverted digital luminescence radiography",
abstract = "Study Design. Observational study with 4 examiners. Objective. To improve the reproducibility and reliability of coronal curvature measurements. Summary of Background Data. Several different methods have been developed to measure coronal curvature. Inverted digital luminescence radiography may be an additional technique to improve the reliability of measurement methods. Methods. A total of 114 whole spine posterior-Anterior radiographs were collected to compare the reliability of 4 measurement methods used in early onset scoliosis. Each radiograph was measured twice by each of 4 examiners using 4 measurement methods with normal and inversion views. Data were analyzed to determine inter-And intraobserver reliabilities. Results. For all 4 methods, the overall intraobserver ICCs were greater than 0.926 and the interobserver ICCs were greater than 0.902, indicating excellent reliability. When intraobserver reliability was assessed in relation to scoliosis severity ( <20°, 20°-40°, and > 40°), the ICCs were higher for greater degrees of curvature; nonetheless, these values were in the excellent range for all methods and were higher for inversion (>0.908) than normal (>0.838) radiographs. For interobserver comparisons, the ICCs were better for the pedicle method (normal: >0.795, inversion: >0.831) than for the other methods (normal: >0.532, inversion: >0.590), with inverted digital luminescence radiography showing the higher ICCs. Conclusion. Inversion radiographs showed high reliability and may increase reliability in cases of less deformed spines. In addition, the pedicle method led to higher ICCs for all measurements regardless of severity, especially on inversion radiographs.",
keywords = "Intraclass correlation coeffi cient, Inverted digital luminescence radiograph, Pedicle method, Reliability analysis",
author = "Jae-Young Hong and Hwang, {Jin Ho} and Seung-Woo Suh and Yang, {Jae Hyuk} and Kim, {Jung Ryeol} and Bae, {Yoon Gwang}",
year = "2015",
doi = "10.1097/BRS.0000000000000875",
language = "English",
volume = "40",
pages = "E701--E712",
journal = "Spine",
issn = "0362-2436",
publisher = "Lippincott Williams and Wilkins",
number = "12",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Reliability of coronal curvature measures in premature scoliosis

T2 - Comparison of 4 methods using inverted digital luminescence radiography

AU - Hong, Jae-Young

AU - Hwang, Jin Ho

AU - Suh, Seung-Woo

AU - Yang, Jae Hyuk

AU - Kim, Jung Ryeol

AU - Bae, Yoon Gwang

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - Study Design. Observational study with 4 examiners. Objective. To improve the reproducibility and reliability of coronal curvature measurements. Summary of Background Data. Several different methods have been developed to measure coronal curvature. Inverted digital luminescence radiography may be an additional technique to improve the reliability of measurement methods. Methods. A total of 114 whole spine posterior-Anterior radiographs were collected to compare the reliability of 4 measurement methods used in early onset scoliosis. Each radiograph was measured twice by each of 4 examiners using 4 measurement methods with normal and inversion views. Data were analyzed to determine inter-And intraobserver reliabilities. Results. For all 4 methods, the overall intraobserver ICCs were greater than 0.926 and the interobserver ICCs were greater than 0.902, indicating excellent reliability. When intraobserver reliability was assessed in relation to scoliosis severity ( <20°, 20°-40°, and > 40°), the ICCs were higher for greater degrees of curvature; nonetheless, these values were in the excellent range for all methods and were higher for inversion (>0.908) than normal (>0.838) radiographs. For interobserver comparisons, the ICCs were better for the pedicle method (normal: >0.795, inversion: >0.831) than for the other methods (normal: >0.532, inversion: >0.590), with inverted digital luminescence radiography showing the higher ICCs. Conclusion. Inversion radiographs showed high reliability and may increase reliability in cases of less deformed spines. In addition, the pedicle method led to higher ICCs for all measurements regardless of severity, especially on inversion radiographs.

AB - Study Design. Observational study with 4 examiners. Objective. To improve the reproducibility and reliability of coronal curvature measurements. Summary of Background Data. Several different methods have been developed to measure coronal curvature. Inverted digital luminescence radiography may be an additional technique to improve the reliability of measurement methods. Methods. A total of 114 whole spine posterior-Anterior radiographs were collected to compare the reliability of 4 measurement methods used in early onset scoliosis. Each radiograph was measured twice by each of 4 examiners using 4 measurement methods with normal and inversion views. Data were analyzed to determine inter-And intraobserver reliabilities. Results. For all 4 methods, the overall intraobserver ICCs were greater than 0.926 and the interobserver ICCs were greater than 0.902, indicating excellent reliability. When intraobserver reliability was assessed in relation to scoliosis severity ( <20°, 20°-40°, and > 40°), the ICCs were higher for greater degrees of curvature; nonetheless, these values were in the excellent range for all methods and were higher for inversion (>0.908) than normal (>0.838) radiographs. For interobserver comparisons, the ICCs were better for the pedicle method (normal: >0.795, inversion: >0.831) than for the other methods (normal: >0.532, inversion: >0.590), with inverted digital luminescence radiography showing the higher ICCs. Conclusion. Inversion radiographs showed high reliability and may increase reliability in cases of less deformed spines. In addition, the pedicle method led to higher ICCs for all measurements regardless of severity, especially on inversion radiographs.

KW - Intraclass correlation coeffi cient

KW - Inverted digital luminescence radiograph

KW - Pedicle method

KW - Reliability analysis

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84942608774&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84942608774&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1097/BRS.0000000000000875

DO - 10.1097/BRS.0000000000000875

M3 - Article

C2 - 25768689

AN - SCOPUS:84942608774

VL - 40

SP - E701-E712

JO - Spine

JF - Spine

SN - 0362-2436

IS - 12

ER -